"We tried to be better, but we aren't. I don't think anyone could last more than a week here if they weren't willing to do bad things." - Alba Reyes

Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
DealsFor.me - The best sales, coupons, and discounts for you
Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Well, at that time I did not know that Persy was scum

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Seth Crimson
Dec 26 2014, 02:00 PM
Un-Persona
 
And you jumped on the MW wagon because...?


I voted MurderWeasel because we're actually going to get something out of that lynch. Because fankly trying to get people to lynch Decoy and Boogie at this point is pointless, not only because Boogie will probably be modkilled if he doesn't say anything, but because we've already tried to lynch decoy in the last phase and look at how that ended.
This. Mostly. Then Persy asked Seth further.

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Welp, I fosed Gianni since Day 1 or 2, I think. He does seem scummy, but my early-game reads aren't as strong as late-game reads. But his hammer seems towny.

Seth seems town as well, although he did not contribute much, his interaction with Persy was non-partnerish.

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
3 protective roles? Seriously? Was OOTS that much about protecting people? I could imagine this kind of setup in a Grey's Anatomy or Scrubs mafia or so, I guess.

But yeah, Persy, who was maf, mentioned there being a bulletproof townie. Welp, as there's another doctor, that shouldn't be the case.

Resource Thread
oh, I thought Medic was alluding to Hansel.

Anyways these lists are very helpful! Thank you very much, everybody.

I'll edit a list in this post, in case I find something useful.

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Vote: Murderweasal

Persy does not look very scummy to me. Rather, Seth's sheeping is more suspicious.

And nope, I won't hammer this time.

New General SOTF Discussion Thread
I got curious about V4. Or rather the rescue. I'm curious about what the V4 handlers thought when the rescue was announced. I think that most people were probably glad about it or rather surprised. What were your thoughts and reactions for the escape? And what were your plans? And how did you guys reacted to the blacklist? I wonder whether the handlers of the blacklist characters thought "Dang it, now my character can't escape" or "Well, I feel honoured to handle one of these few special mentioned characters" (Well, to be honest, I read some blacklist characters just because they were on the blacklist, which certainly makes them stand out from the 276 students.). I also kinda wonder why people chose to rescue one of their characters instead of another one of theirs. But yeah, the rescue is such an interesting event in SOTF history. That makes me think how people reacted to the V3 Epilogue/Escape.

Oh dang, another Random Thought of mine occured. Which V5 students would've been on the ban list? (I think this question was already asked for V1-3 or Minis. I don't recall.)

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Okay. So if we lynch Toben, who brings activity in the game, we might all die due to inactivity.

So, I'll vote Toben, if you promise me to talk everything out.

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Welp, the votes are split. Who're we gonna lynch? Boogie or KV?

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Well, there are Na´ve Doctors (or Quacks) in mafia, which means they can target people but they cannot save people. So I assume they could've been Na´ve Bodyguards as well. That'd explain the multiple protective roles in combination with the no-kill. Either that or this setup is made for protective roles. Say, did OOTS have many people who protect?

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
What. So you actually believed that lyncher claim, Toben? I'm confused. How do you react if I claim, for example, Cthulu or Survivor?

So the no night kill was certainly weird. I really doubt that the mafia failed to kill somebody, especially as the night was extended. So they either decided to not kill anyone, which is very improbable, because it'd make no sense or there's a bulletproof or another protective role. That however also would be weird, considering that 2 protective roles are already confirmed in the game (and dead). So having 3 protective roles would be pretty weird. Maybe the bodyguards that died weren't bodyguards, maybe they couldn't protect anybody.

Are we gonna lynch somebody today? Does anybody have important infos? Not everybody spoke, yet.

Project: Wiki
Will the terrorist page be updated, as there's now a number of new terrorists (Or should I try to do that)? Also I'm curious who people like "Niki Montgomery" or "Shane Kimblee" are. IIRC they were announced in neither V1-5 nor in the V0 story.

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Welcome!

So...my opinion is decoy is that he's not scummy and his defense sounds pretty reasonable. The only scummy thing of him is that he's not very active (but not many of us, are).

The Vyse/Slam townreads are pretty reasonable, which could turn bad for us, in case they're scum. But I doubt both of them would be scum at the same time, because then we'd be screwed.

Naft and Toben are pretty much productive and do scum hunt. They're both good mafia players, so I cannot trust them, although the fact that Naft scumreads Toben is very, very useful.

Uh, what's been missed...? Not really sure what to think about Persy, he's in contrast to Seth, doing much more. At least they swapped the role of contributing/not contributing during the night. But he's not as active as Naft or Toben.

There aren't many people living, though. I hope an investigation role found mafia. So, who's buddying with whom and who fosses/busses whom? Are there ties? If Naft and Toben are mafia, why'd Naft bus?

V4 Read-A-Thon: The Reboot
I should probably finish my other thousands read and also finish my critique thread, but V4 sounds interesting and I'm gonna have lots of freetime to read it.

Roll me one, please!

V3 Read-A-Thon
Seth Crimson
Dec 16 2014, 05:46 AM
And she gets involved in the escape, where the thread basically turns into a clusterfuck, having to search the thread for where the characters where is frustrating to say the least. And then we don't find out what happens to Terrie, the wiki says she got shot to death in an ambush, but there is nothing like that in the thread.
It got mentioned in the Epilogue from Brad's POV.

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Well, it is sheeping.

While on the one hand there's a risk of losing some PR, on the other there's the chance of hitting maf, as well as the chance to avoid him getting lynched in lylo or so.

So, why'd mafia kill Yugi? I think they either have a role cop, or Yugi looked town. Or they killed randomly. But, who'd kill Yugi? I guess the people who fosed him wouldn't have.

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Which questions, Persy? Ask me questions!

Also, not sure how this decoy lynch is going to turn out. If decoy's a PR, we're not in a good position.

Vote: decoy

But, he isn't helpful at day anyway.

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Oh, Goose, my last question was directed towards you, btw.

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Seth is not doing anything, so he's null. Either useless town or dangerous maf.

Toben is doing stuff, which is cool, but he's a good player, I think, so he could be maf. I can't tell really, I haven't played games with him much.

Vyse is trying to find scum, which makes him town-y for me. The bandwagon post was plausible and he justified why he voted, so why should he be maf?

Gianni claims that I dodged questions, which confuses me. Which questions have I not answered? If you mean Naft's question:

Why'd you push on me, despite the fact that Naft's questions were asked like just some hours ago? This is suspicious.

Order Of The Stick Mafia Game Thread
Ah, I see.

But my explanation was that Espi and Vyse wouldn't talk that way on day 1 as allied scum. I mean, why'd they say in the night phase "Let's ask questions to each other and suspect each other"? I thought that they couldn't be maf together, it wouldn't make sense them talking that way.